Wilshire Phoenix Rejection

Wilshire Phoenix Built a Clever ETF: SEC Rejected It Anyway

Last Updated on: November 22, 2026

Spot Bitcoin ETFs finally launched in January 2024, more than a decade after the first application was filed. 

Getting there required the ground to move in several directions at once. 

To understand how far, it helps to look at where things stood in December 2019… when the SEC delayed a decision on Wilshire Phoenix’s proposal until February 2020… and when the pitch was a clever structure rather than a plain one.

The SEC Delay

On December 20, 2019, the SEC published a document announcing that its decision on the Bitcoin ETF proposal filed by Wilshire Phoenix would be pushed to February 2020, with the date set at February 26.

The proposal had been filed that summer.

SEC logo

The delay wasn’t arbitrary… federal statute sets the clock on these decisions and allows the agency to extend it, which is why “postponed” is a procedural move rather than a stall tactic. 

During this period of time… the SEC had used the same mechanism repeatedly.

Why the SEC Kept Saying No

Over the preceding two years the regulator rejected more than a dozen applications. 

The best-known, from VanEck and SolidX, was delayed several times before the applicants withdrew it during the government shutdown that winter.

The objections were consistent… surveillance sharing and market manipulation. 

Spot bitcoin trades on venues the SEC doesn’t oversee, and manipulation on those venues would flow directly into the price of any fund holding the asset. 

The SEC wanted the underlying market surveilled by a regulated exchange before it would bless a product tied to it. 

Until that was solved… no application was getting through.

Wilshire’s Pitch

Wilshire Phoenix believed it had solved both problems, and for a while plenty of people thought its application might be the first approved. 

Founder and managing partner William Herrmann said the proposal could protect against price volatility.

The mechanism was the interesting part… if volatility rose, the trust would rebalance automatically… cutting bitcoin exposure and raising Treasury bill exposure… if volatility fell, it moved the other way. 

A volatility-managed trust, in other words… BTC with a shock absorber bolted on.

It’s worth noting what that structure costs. 

Every rebalance is a sale, and every sale is a taxable event, so the shock absorber generates a tax bill each time it engages.

The Comment Letter

Wilshire was confident enough to file a comment letter with the SEC on December 18, 2019… two days before the delay was announced. 

Herrmann told CoinDesk the letter argued that the two relevant markets… the CME bitcoin futures market and the spot market made up of the five exchanges feeding the CME CF Bitcoin Reference Rate… were the “regulated markets of significant size” the Commission kept asking about.

The argument was essentially that a surveilled futures market plus a reference rate built from named exchanges added up to enough oversight… the SEC had heard versions of that before.

The Bitwise Rejection

Days earlier, the SEC had rejected an application from Bitwise Asset Management on the same grounds. 

That rejection was still under review by the Commissioners, with no timeline for a final decision.

How It Ended

Wilshire’s application didn’t get there. 

The SEC disapproved it in February 2020, and the reasoning was familiar… the surveillance arrangements still didn’t satisfy the standard.

The eventual approvals came by a different route entirely… 

In August 2023 a court ruled that the SEC’s rejection of Grayscale’s conversion application was arbitrary and capricious, and the agency declined to appeal. 

Spot Bitcoin ETFs launched in January 2024… plain vanilla… physically backed… no rebalancing mechanism. 

The clever structure turned out not to be the unlock… the surveillance question did… and it was settled by losing in court rather than by a better pitch.

Four Years Is a Long Time

The 2019 version of this story reads like a project on the verge… it wasn’t. 

Wilshire had a genuinely novel design, a confident founder, and a comment letter arguing the right points, and it still got rejected two months later on the same grounds as everyone else.

What actually changed between then and approval was not the sophistication of the proposals. 

It was a court ruling that removed the SEC’s discretion to keep saying no.

 Anyone building in this space should take the lesson: a better argument doesn’t move a regulator that has decided… a judgment does.

You don't have permission to register