LBRY Loses to SEC

Court Rules LBRY Token Is a Security

Last Updated on: November 21, 2026

Following the ICO surge in 2017, the SEC spent years working through tokens launched in that period, sorting utility from unregistered security. 

In March 2022 that work reached LBRY, a decentralized content platform. 

On November 7, 2022, Judge Paul J. Barbadoro of the U.S. District Court for New Hampshire granted the SEC summary judgment and declared the LBC token a security. 

The ruling is a significant moment, and the details matter more than the headline.

The Ruling

The SEC accused LBRY of selling a security token while claiming LBC was a utility cryptocurrency. 

The court applied the Howey test, the decades-old standard for determining whether an asset is a security under federal securities law, and found the SEC’s assessment correct.

LBRY vs SEC

What makes the ruling notable is what the court leaned on… it relied heavily on LBRY’s own public statements about the token… the team’s own optimism about LBC’s value was used as evidence that buyers expected profit from the efforts of others. 

That’s an uncomfortable precedent for any project that talks up its own token.

It’s also worth being precise about the procedural posture… this was a summary judgment… not a trial. 

No full factual record was developed, and LBRY never got to argue context in front of a jury. Critics of the decision point to exactly that.

The Precedent Behind It

The LBRY decision didn’t arrive in a vacuum. 

The SEC had already won similar cases against Kik and Telegram, and the courts in each instance worked through the specific details of the token in front of them. 

That’s the only method used… fact-specific analysis, case by case… no sweeping rule.

There’s still a live debate about whether tokens should be regulated as securities at all, and a smaller one about whether the SEC should be the agency doing it. 

That argument is happening inside the crypto community and among regulators themselves.

Why XRP May Be Different

The obvious read is that LBRY’s loss spells trouble for Ripple. Crypto Law founder John Deaton argues the opposite, for three specific reasons…

First, the two cases sit in completely separate federal circuits. 

Second, LBRY’s attorney conceded the first two prongs of the Howey test and disputed only the third, while Ripple’s attorneys have challenged all three. [LINK: RIPPLE VICTORY]

Third, the LBRY ruling was shaped by prior precedent in the same circuit… precedent Ripple’s court doesn’t have to follow.

Deaton also notes that XRP’s utility has been put before the court repeatedly, and that numerous firms have offered amicus briefs arguing XRP isn’t a security.

What LBRY Actually Is

LBRY logo

LBRY is a content-sharing platform built to use blockchain for distributing digital content… images, video, files, anything. 

The goal was a decentralized alternative to YouTube, Twitch, and Instagram.

That matters because the platform spent years under exactly the kind of pressure decentralized media is supposed to solve. 

LBRY fought YouTube for years over its own channel… watching videos get demonetized and its audience redirected to a mirror site… while simultaneously carrying the regulatory weight of its own token.

For a site that covers censorship, LBRY is a case study rather than an abstraction.

LBC is the platform’s native currency, used to publish content, create channels, tip creators, and boost posts… it can be mined, earned through network activity, or bought on exchanges that list it.

And here’s the detail that drove the case… LBRY never ran an ICO. 

The team kept 400 million LBC as a premine… out of a total supply of roughly 1.08 billion… and released tokens on secondary exchanges to fund operations. 

LBRY’s representatives leaned on the absence of an ICO in court, arguing it proved LBC wasn’t a security. The court decided that wasn’t enough.

What Comes Next

Determining which tokens are securities will be a long and contentious road. 

Some tokens are designed as security tokens from the start, which sidesteps the question entirely. 

Most aren’t, and for those the analysis stays case by case.

LBRY would go on to appeal the decision before running out of money entirely… a story for another article. [LINK: LBRY appeal and bankruptcy]

Ruling Narrower Than the Headline

The temptation is to read this as the SEC running the table… it isn’t quite that. 

The court applied an existing test to specific facts and reached a defensible conclusion, and in doing so it handed the regulator a win without settling much of anything.

What it did settle is that a premine sold on secondary markets can be a security even without an ICO… and that a team’s own marketing can be used against it. 

Both are worth knowing before you launch anything or buy into it. 

The XRP case will turn on different facts in a different circuit, and Deaton’s read is that it may well go the other way. Watch the reasoning, not the scoreboard.

The penalty tells you most of what you need to know. 

The court set the fine at $111,614… roughly what a mid-size project spends on a month of development… and LBRY could not pay it. 

The SEC won the ruling and effectively ended the defendant in the same motion.

You don't have permission to register